Loading

AMI’s Best Kept Secrets

With no chain stores on our seven miles of pristine paradise (you won’t see a certain popular Seattle-based coffee company anywhere for example), the quaint boutiques and shops on Anna Maria Island are an ever-evolving experience, delivering a unique adventure any and every time you walk into their storefronts. 

This list is just a small selection of the cute and quaint stores that await you on your next visit.  


inside of pet supply store

Don’t forget to save space in your carry-on to pack a goodie or treat for your favorite pet or pet-lover at AMI Beach & Dog Supply. This place isn’t just for the dogs. There are items for cats and other pets at this storefront on Pine Avenue.  

Interior of COVE with a feature wall

COVE is a haven for not only coastal themed gifts but also a place to showcase local artists and their ocean-inspired work. Even the floor is in a beach state of mind – it’s a hand painted waterscape rendering from the sand to the deep ocean. Walk away smiling with any number of treasures, from original paintings and reclaimed wood art to jewelry, clothing, glasswork and gifts for the young and young at heart.

exterior of Olive Oil Outpost

Our vibrant culinary scene caters to a range of palates with our fresh-catch seafood and Floribbean flavors. If you’re housed at one of our vacation rentals and want to stay in and prepare your own meal, a stop at the Olive Oil Outpost on Pine Avenue is a must. Paired with 20 years of experience, the Olive Oil Outpost has the skinny on premium olive oils, balsamic vinegars, sauces, condiments and other culinary products like pastas.  

interior of Island Cabana

Now celebrating 15 years on Anna Maria Island, The Island Cabana highlights designer and fashion apparel and home décor for the resort lifestyle conscious buyer. This boutique’s stylish pop with vibrant colors and designs. The array of island souvenirs has something for the entire family.  

Beach Bums Bikes & Woody Car

Want an eco-friendly way to travel from boutique to boutique? Beach Bums is the way to haul all your newfound ‘fits and furnishings. They have an expansive fleet of electric-only golf carts (street-legal on Anna Maria Island) and bikes, along with paddle boards and kayaks. Don’t worry about packing any beach supplies – Beach Bums has you covered with its gift shop to help commemorate your trip with souvenirs. 

Tiny Treasures and Quaint Shops and Spots

Tucked away in Holmes Beach, you’ll find Isola Bella Italian Eatery, a cozy spot serving up housemade Italian favorites inspired by the flavors of Sicily. From handmade pasta and from-scratch sauces to daily entrée specials and a tempting dessert list, indulge in the taste of authentic Italian cuisine. Buon appetito!

outside of Island Charms

Island Charms offers a thoughtfully curated selection of housewares, gift items, and handcrafted jewelry, featuring both local and global designers. Their passion for unique accessories shines through in every piece. Whether you’re looking for a beachside memento, a special gift, or a personal treat, their custom-fitted Forever Bracelets and Anklets—available in 14k gold, gold-filled, and silver—can be personalized with charms and jewels for a distinctive touch.

Inside of Beach Blossom Studio

If you can’t live by the coast year-round, take some pieces of paradise home from the Beach Blossom Studio. These creative offerings are on two prime locations on Anna Maria Island – the north end on Pine Avenue, aka, “the greenest Main Street in America” and on the south end in Bradenton Beach on Bridge Street. Beach Blossom is committed to creative and quality decorative items for your home or your wardrobe.  

Tiny Treasures and Quaint Shops and Spots

Borne out of the sisterhood between two friends, this collection features quality and responsibly sourced products. Their racks will reinvigorate your closet with everything from high-end maxi dresses, cashmere crewnecks and classy cardigans to retro tees. It’s a space where natural art, jewelry, handmade clothing and home furnishings all have a purpose.  

Tiny Treasures and Quaint Shops and Spots

Tucked away on Bridge Street, Bamboo Island Bar brings a vibrant slice of Brazil to Bradenton Beach! Head upstairs to this cozy spot and enjoy a laid-back evening with stunning views, colorful tiled stairs, and a menu that takes you on a world tour. From Brazilian Picanha to Spanish-inspired sautéed octopus, there’s something here for every palate.

Tiny Treasures and Quaint Shops and Spots

Find Your Perfect Beach

Our picturesque slice of Florida’s West Coast offers a quintessential beach getaway like no other.

Tiny Treasures and Quaint Shops and Spots

Love it Like a Local

Join locals and fellow visitors alike in efforts to leave the area as beautiful as we found.